Home

Research School Network: Boys Inclusion Starts with Being Known Co-director James Crane relfects on our work with ​“The Boys Impact Hub” to ensure boys in our school feel known & valued

Blog


Boys Inclusion Starts with Being Known

Co-director James Crane relfects on our work with ​“The Boys Impact Hub” to ensure boys in our school feel known & valued

by Durrington Research School
on the

It is easy to talk about boys’ attainment, attendance, behaviour or engagement. We can analyse the data, identify trends and compare outcomes. There is no denying that these things matter. But the more I delve into this work, the more I find myself returning to a much simpler question:

Do the boys in our schools feel known and valued?


Over the last two years, through our work at Durrington Research School with the Boys Impact Hub, we here at Durrington High School have explored attainment gaps, patterns of engagement and the experiences of boys in school. What we found was that a significant number of our boys were attending school sporadically and, even when present, were not fully engaging in the wider life of the school.

Many were not focused or working hard in lessons. They were frequently removed due to disruptive behaviour or a lack of engagement. Their behaviour records contained far more negative points than positive ones. They were not attending clubs, enrichment activities or revision sessions. School felt like something they had to get through. Life in school was about surviving rather than thriving.

We then spent time reviewing the interventions and strategies we had put in place to support these boys. This was where the penny really dropped. We had been making too many assumptions about behaviours, attitudes and the reasons behind them.

Through the Boys Impact work, and by listening to Professor Alex Blower, I came to a simple but important realisation: our boys did not need more judgements or assumptions; they needed adults who were prepared to listen, understand their experiences and recognise their potential. So that is what we did next, we listened.

We focused on building relationships, developing understanding and creating opportunities for meaningful conversations about the realities and challenges of being a boy today. What quickly became apparent was that aspiration was rarely the issue.

The boys did not lack ambition. What many lacked was agency. They lacked opportunities to set meaningful goals and to see themselves as active participants in their own futures. School often felt disconnected from the lives they imagined for themselves. They had not yet joined the dots between what happened in the classroom and where they wanted to be in the future.

I will be exploring the nuance, context and practical realities of this work in greater detail at the UnlockED Inclusion event.

The more we discussed inclusion, the less we found ourselves talking about boys as a category and the more we found ourselves talking about young people as individuals.

​“What do you want to do as a career? What do you want to do next year to support this?“


At first glance, this appears to be a conversation about aspiration. In reality, it is a conversation about identity. It says to a young person:

​“I am interested in your future. I believe there is a future worth talking about. Your ambitions matter here.“


For some boys, particularly those who have experienced challenge, disadvantage or repeated academic struggle, that message cannot be taken for granted. Too often, discussions about boys drift towards what they are not doing. They are not reading enough. They are not engaging enough. They are not achieving enough. They are not motivated enough. If we start there, however, we risk creating narratives that reduce possibility rather than expand it.

This is why I keep returning to a quote from Dan Nicholls:

​“I don’t need a label. I need equity. I need you to notice me, know me, teach me and support me to step forward.“


The same principle applies to our boys. Before they are attendance figures, attainment data points or behaviour records, they are individuals with strengths, interests, ambitions and experiences. For me, this is where inclusion begins. Not with interventions or programmes, but with relationships.

As Tom Bennett reminds us, relationships are built on predictability, consistency and the growing certainty that a teacher has a genuine regard for a student. Relationships are built, not bought. This aligns with the work of Osher et al. (2019), which identifies relationships as one of the key mechanisms through which children develop, learn and adapt to their environments. Positive, supportive and trusting relationships are not simply a desirable addition to learning; they are part of its foundation.

The importance of this becomes even clearer when viewed through the lens of Self-Determination Theory (Deci & Ryan, 2000). The theory suggests that human motivation is driven, in part, by the need for relatedness (the feeling that we belong and are valued by others). When young people experience genuine belonging, they are more likely to engage, persist and invest effort. For many boys, belonging is not something we should assume. It is something we must intentionally build.

Many boys arrive in our schools carrying uncertainty. Some are unsure whether they will succeed academically. Some are trying hard not to appear vulnerable. Others have experienced repeated setbacks that have gradually shaped what they believe is possible. It is incumbent upon us, as school leaders, teachers and educators, to understand this.

This is where we matter. The conversation at the classroom door, the remembered interest, the question about football training, the recognition of an excellent answer, or the praise for a piece of work that demonstrates real effort. Individually, these moments may appear insignificant. Collectively, they can be transformational.

Vygotsky (1978) argued that learning is fundamentally social. Long before students engage deeply with content, they engage with people. Often, the relationship becomes the bridge between uncertainty and participation. Even our expectations matter. Rosenthal and Jacobson’s work on teacher expectations reminds us that what adults believe about young people can influence what those young people come to believe about themselves. When our interactions communicate belief, possibility and potential, we help students begin to see those things for themselves.

Perhaps the challenge for schools is not simply to ask, ​“How do we improve outcomes for boys?” Instead, the more important question might be: ​“How do we create environments where boys feel visible, valued and capable of success?“

The reason is simple. When boys believe that adults know them, understand them and genuinely expect them to succeed, something powerful begins to happen. Attendance becomes more meaningful, engagement becomes more likely and aspiration becomes more believable. Inclusion becomes more than a strategy; it becomes a lived experience.


The challenge of boys’ inclusion will not be solved through a single intervention, programme or initiative. As Marc Rowland often reminds us, meaningful change is built through thousands of daily interactions that communicate belief, belonging and possibility. By ensuring boys feel seen, understood and connected, we create the conditions in which they can thrive.

James Crane

Co-director Durrington Research School


This website collects a number of cookies from its users for improving your overall experience of the site.Read more