Home

Research School Network: Making room for ​‘I don’t know’: a small change to checking for understanding By Dr Niki Kaiser, Director of Norfolk Research School

Blog


Making room for ​‘I don’t know’: a small change to checking for understanding

By Dr Niki Kaiser, Director of Norfolk Research School

What if one of the most useful answers a pupil could give us was ​‘I don’t know’?

Last week, during a discussion about checking for understanding, a colleague raised an interesting question.

Thinking about how we might multiple-choice questions, with pupils showing one, two, three or four fingers to indicate their chosen answer, they wondered whether we should also allow pupils to show no fingers at all.

If we’re genuinely trying to find out what pupils know and don’t know, is it helpful to make them choose an answer when they’re completely unsure? Wouldn’t it be more useful to know that they don’t know, rather than have them guess or copy the response of someone sitting nearby?

It was a question that stayed with me.

Trying something different

Today, I was teaching my Year 12 chemistry class. I’d given them a set of multiple-choice questions to complete independently as a starter, and had identified several questions that I wanted to use from the set to check their understanding.

My plan was to ask pupils to write their chosen answers for selected questions on mini whiteboards and hold them up, so that I could see the range of responses before revealing the correct answer.

But before we started, I decided to explain why I use mini whiteboards.

I told them there were two reasons.

The first was about confidence. As A‑level chemistry students, they are young people who have experienced academic success. They might not always feel confident, but they wouldn’t be sitting in that classroom if they hadn’t succeeded at school. And sometimes, I think that experience of success can make the possibility of being wrong feel particularly uncomfortable. Answering a question publicly can feel risky.

Mini whiteboards help because everyone responds, and no single pupil is put on the spot.

The second reason was about my learning as a teacher. I explained that I genuinely wanted to know what they understood and, just as importantly, what they didn’t understand. Of course I’d be delighted if everyone knew every answer, but if that happened every time, perhaps I wouldn’t be asking sufficiently challenging questions.

I wanted to identify the things they were uncertain about, because those were the things I could help them with.

So I introduced a small change. When I asked them to show their answers, I said they should write a question mark if they genuinely didn’t know, rather than feeling they had to guess.

What did I learn?

The results were interesting and helpful, and I’ll definitely do this again.

On the very first question I selected, around a quarter of the class gave the same incorrect answer. It revealed a clear misconception that I could address immediately. This was exactly the sort of information I hoped to gather through checking for understanding.

But something different happened with some of the other questions.

For a couple of questions, almost everyone answered correctly with perhaps one or two incorrect answers. But there were also one or two question marks.

Those question marks were particularly enlightening.

Without them, I might have seen a largely correct set of responses, addressed the occasional error and moved on. But the question marks told me something additional: there were pupils who didn’t feel able to commit to an answer at all.

That gave me a reason to revisit the idea briefly and, importantly, to check back with them later to see whether their understanding had improved.

What are we actually trying to find out?

This experience has made me reflect on what we mean by checking for understanding.

A multiple-choice response can give us useful information about what pupils think. Carefully designed distractors can reveal misconceptions, and the distribution of answers can help us decide what to teach next.

But a selected answer doesn’t necessarily tell us whether a pupil knows, thinks they know, is making an educated guess or has simply chosen an option at random.

Allowing pupils to indicate uncertainty adds another piece of information.

Of course, a question mark isn’t a perfect diagnostic tool either. It might mean a pupil has no idea, or it might mean they have some understanding but lack confidence. We still need to ask further questions to work out what support is needed.

Nevertheless, making uncertainty visible gives us something useful to respond to.

And perhaps there’s an important message for pupils here too. If we want classrooms in which pupils are willing to take risks, make mistakes and learn from them, we need to make it safe to admit uncertainty.

In this lesson, a very small change helped me distinguish between a widely held misconception and individual pupils who weren’t confident in their understanding. Both were useful, but they prompted slightly different responses from me.

Adaptive teaching depends on gathering information about pupils’ learning and responding to it. Perhaps sometimes that means giving pupils permission not to know.

I’ll certainly be making more room for question marks on my mini whiteboards.

Thanks to Tammy Elward, Corinne Settle and Rachael Wilson for reminding me that, even if you’ve been teaching for ​“a while”, there’s still always so much to reflect on and learn.


Further reading:
https://educationendowmentfoundation.org.uk/news/effective-teacher-feedback-understanding-in-adaptive-teaching
https://educationendowmentfoundation.org.uk/news/understanding-feedback-guides-teaching

This website collects a number of cookies from its users for improving your overall experience of the site.Read more