Blog -
Meet our new Evidence Leads in Education
ELEs use research and evidence to improve their schools and networks. They’re experts in supporting schools through change.
This website collects a number of cookies from its users for improving your overall experience of the site.
Share on:
by East London Research School
on the
Half a million people have given their views about the early years: now it’s time for all of us in early years, childcare and education to think through what people have told us, writes Julian Grenier.
A couple of years ago, the Education Endowment Foundation’s report on Working with parents to support children’s learning neatly summarised a challenge.
Working with parents is important. Levels of parental engagement are consistently associated with better academic outcomes. The biggest research study into the early years in England, the EPPSE project, similarly found that the home learning environment had the biggest impact on children’s early development. A high-quality home learning environment has an even bigger impact than high-quality early education and childcare. That finding remained true even when parental income and qualifications were controlled for.
With parenting, it’s not who you are that makes the difference.
It’s what you do.
So where is the challenge?
The problem is that we don’t know how to involve all parents in ways that support children’s learning. In a nutshell, parents who are already keen to support their children’s learning are also keen to engage in activities and workshops run by Children’s Centres, early years settings and schools.
But those we’d most like to reach, are the least likely to come along. If they do come along, they are the most likely to drop out of programmes.
This has, of course, been especially significant during the Covid-19 pandemic. With many young children locked down, the home learning environment has become even more important. We learnt at lot at East London Research School about ways to support children locked down or self-isolating at home. We shared our learning in a series of blogs, starting here.
This still feels like an emergent area of practice and research. The Royal Foundation’s findings have made me stop and think.
With half a million responses, we should certainly take heart: the public is really interested in what makes a difference to children’s futures.
But we should also be concerned. For decades, we’ve been sharing the evidence that it’s the first five years which are the most important time for children’s development.
We’ve tried our hardest to get that message across.
We haven’t succeeded, yet.
Only a quarter of parents recognise that. There is also a low level of awareness that the most significant period of brain development is from birth to two years old.
The report also gives us a worrying insight into the mental health of parents. The pandemic has heightened anxiety and stress amongst parents. My first-hand experience suggests that this has been an underlying issue for many years, especially in poorer neighbourhoods which are blighted by violence, crime, racism, bad housing and a poor overall environment. These are places which are hostile to childhood.
That tells me that we need to work to improve family life in England, and create family and child-friendly spaces. We need to offer much more help to parents who struggle with poor mental health.
Focusing on what we can do directly in early years, we can make a very positive difference to the lives of young children and their families by providing high-quality early education and childcare. Early Years settings are often the only safe, warm and inviting places for children in their neighbourhoods.
But it also strikes me that some of our efforts to engage parents might be triggering those difficult feelings that have been reported, of anxiety and insecurity. By trying to do something good, we might inadvertently be causing harm. The Royal Foundation’s finding about how many parents feel ‘judged’ is worrying.
Many of us send out lots of ideas for home learning. We invite parents in for workshops so they can learn about how to help their child. Aren’t these exactly the types of activities which might lead to parents feeling ‘judged’?
It’s easy to imagine how a parent might feel they aren’t doing enough.
Or they might feel that others are doing a much better job than them.
It’s easy to imagine how growing anxiety and a feeling of being judged might lead a parent not to engage with their child’s setting, or with other local services.
Let’s stop and consider what matters most to young children. The WHO has recently published guidelines on improving early childhood development for children from birth to 3 years old. They make the important point that there are many different components of nurturing care for children. Their number one recommendation is both rather obvious, and yet also striking.
So, is there a risk that when we focus so much on early learning, we increase parental anxiety – especially at a time like this?
With increased feelings of anxiety come a diminishing capacity to make time and space for your child. Stress makes it hard to be responsive to your child. It’s all too easy to get into negative cycles of feeling angry or overwhelmed by your child’s needs and demands. I touched on that experience when my pre-term daughter came home from the Special Care Baby Unit and was unsettled, fretful and sleepless. It was a very hard time.
What worries me especially, is that the most vulnerable parents will probably suffer the most. In turn, their children will probably miss out the most. We need to do much more to support parents in offering their children consistent and responsive caregiving.
That isn’t to say that early learning doesn’t matter. It’s hugely important. It’s well established that once children fall behind in their early years, it gets increasingly difficult for them to catch up. Children who leave school without basic skills in communication, reading, writing and maths are more likely to live in poverty as adults and to have poorer physical and mental health.
What I’m arguing is that we need to make sure we prioritise children’s and parents’ wellbeing. We need to be aware of the powerful feelings of ‘being judged’ that many parents have, and how these feelings can tip into anxiety. We need to build our work with both children and parents on the solid foundations or warm and responsive relationships with clear boundaries.
That’s why the virtual destruction of the Children’s Centre programme in recent years is so lamentable, and so likely to hit disadvantaged children the hardest. As A couple of years ago, the Sutton Trust commented that ‘we need to stop the piecemeal closure of these vital community resources’. Sadly, more have closed since then. It doesn’t even feel piecemeal any more.
So are there any ways forward? Whilst this is a very difficult time for all of us in the early years, it’s also a good time to start thinking about how we might rebuild and do things differently.
Here are three suggestions:
Blog -
ELEs use research and evidence to improve their schools and networks. They’re experts in supporting schools through change.
Blog -
Over-crowded housing leads to poorer self-regulation in young children? It’s not so simple, argues researcher Hope Oloye.
Blog -
In this final blog, we hear from the Grove Nursery School and the organisations KeepMi and EasyPeasy